Professional Athletes
| David Buehler | Football | Class of 2005 | Dallas Cowboys |
| John Cummings | Baseball | Class of 1988 | Seattle Mariners |
| Christian Colon | Baseball | Class of 2007 | Kansas City Royals |
| Rob Deer | Baseball | Class of 1978 | San Francisco Giants |
| Grant Green | Baseball | Class of 2006 | Oakland A’s |
| Doug Linton | Baseball | Class of 1983 | Toronto Blue Jays |
| Doug Neely | Soccer | Class of 1983 | New England Revolution |
| Vinnie Pestano | Baseball | Class of 2003 | Cleveland Indians |
| Craig Ritter | Football | Class of 1991 | Houston Oilers |
| Steve Scarsone | Baseball | Class of 1984 | Philadelphia Phillies |
| Chris Snitko | Soccer | Class of 1992 | Kansas City Wizards (MLS) |
| Eric Valent | Baseball | Class of 1995 | Philadelphia Phillies |
Olympians
Courtney Mathewson – Women’s Water Polo – 2012 & 2016 Olympics – Gold Medalist
